I feel your pain. The teachers in our school are embracing new ways of thinking about education, and we're moving forward. But we have raised a generation of kids who are used to being spoon-fed. They are grade-driven, focused on AP exams and college admissions, and they just want to know if this is on the test. And if it is, they want to know if they've got the right answer. So when we tell them that in this unit, they're going to figure out the problem themselves, and in fact, that they have to ask the right questions to determine what the problem even is, they revolt. It's understandable. But don't give in! You love your kiddos and you want to help them, but you're not helping them by returning to your standard "Open the book to page 156 and do Exercise 7" lesson. So how do you help them and you through this transition? To me, there are two important ways we can help them - creating authentic assessments and creating space for feedback and
revisions.
Authentic Assessments - How do you get out of the "Open the book" mentality? My advice to
teachers is to start at the end and work backwards. Let me ask you something. If you want to know whether or not the surgeon operating on you knows what she's doing, would you want to know her answers to a written test? Would you assess your hairdresser based on a multiple choice exam? What do you want your students to be able to do at the end of your lesson?
If I want my French students to be able to speak about where things are located using vocabulary in the house, I should be doing lessons like this: Un Cambriolage which asks students to role-play a burglary scene within very specific parameters, and accurately measures their proficiency. This lesson was found in The Authentic Assessment Toolbox - an excellent resource from Jon Mueller. Professor of Psychology, North Central College, Naperville, IL. Start with the end of the lesson and develop authentic assessments of their skills and knowledge. THEN plan the rest of your lesson around it.
Space for Feedback and Revisions - I love this video The Story of Austin's Butterfly. I first saw it on a visit to High Tech High in San Diego. This powerful video demonstrates very clearly the importance of positive critique and of the revision process itself. Who does things perfectly on the first try? So why do we (and I include myself in this) give students one assessment, mark a grade and done? We know it's much more important for the student to actually master the skills or content. And the more times they get to revise the work, the better they get at it. Isn't that the whole point? I had a professor in graduate school for whom papers were never finished. Every draft I did, he gave feedback and I revised and he gave feedback, and the loop continued until I decided to stop.
Both of these concepts empower students. Empowered students are engaged. Try these two techniques and if they don't work the first time, get the students' feedback and revise! The students will respect you for it and you'll know you're on the right track.



